The Bill of Rights gives Americans the right to free speech, including the right to criticize any country on earth, including our own. But a Florida ‘hate crime’ bill working its way through House committees would interfere with Floridians’ constitutional right to make statements critical of one foreign country: Israel.
Contact Florida lawmakers (info below) and ask them to oppose this bill, which violates some of our fundamental rights.
The United States is in the throes of a free speech crisis.
We have the constitutional right to criticize our own country; we can criticize any country on any continent in the world, but in some states we cannot criticize Israel.
In spite of grave criticism from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), many states have passed, or are passing, bills that suppress our speech when it comes to Israel.
They are doing this through changing the definition of anti-Semitism, and then codifying this new, Israel-centric definition into law.
Israel, in its 70th year of dispossessing indigenous Palestinians, its 51st year of military occupation–using $10.5 million a day of American taxpayer money–ought not to be above criticism. But Florida may soon criminalize criticism of Israel.
Florida bill to police speech
This legislation redefines anti-Semitism and then uses this to prohibit certain statements about Israel. Believe it or not, in Florida, it may soon be considered anti-Semitic to
“[focus] peace or human rights investigations only on Israel”
even though a multitude of international human rights organizations have documented severe abuses by the Israeli military.
If for example you want to criticize Israel’s nightly practice of kidnapping children from their beds, torturing them, and interrogating them in a language they don’t understand–then you’d better find out which other countries are doing that, and criticize them too. If you don’t, you may be a criminal.
Or if you call for a full investigation of Israel’s attack on a U.S. Navy ship that killed 34 American servicemen and wounded over 170, and do not at the same time call for an investigation of Japan for Pearl Harbor, you might also be breaking the proposed Israel-shielding law.
Florida is just the latest of many states and countries under pressure to adopt an Israel-centric definition of anti-Semitism, and then use it to prevent criticism of Israel–even when it is factual.
The South Carolina Senate passed almost identical legislation in 2018; the Israel-centric definition of anti-Semitism, according to experts, will impede free academic inquiry when applied on college campuses. For example, teachers and students may not discuss Israeli human-rights violations.
Legislation suppresses free speech
While the ACLU stays out of the Israeli-Palestinian issue, the organization has taken a strong stand on the Israel-centric definition of anti-Semitism found in this type of legislation:
The bill is part of a disturbing surge of government-led attempts to suppress the speech of people on only one side of the Israel-Palestine debate…Those who seek to protest, boycott, or otherwise criticize the Israeli government are being silenced…campaigns aimed at excluding critics of Israel from participating in public events are mounting.
First Amendment rights belong to the people, not the government. The government cannot impose its views on people or punish them for expressing views that the government disagrees with.
This is not the first time that Randy Fine has tried to protect Israel by suppressing free speech. In February 2018 he tried to pressure venues to cancel concerts starring Lorde because she had taken a stand against Israel’s treatment of Palestinians. Rep. Fine’s reasoning was based on pro-Israel legislation already in place outlawing boycotts of Israel (this legislation also appears to violate the U.S. Constitution).
The new bill is even broader in scope.
Please contact the following Florida legislators
You can contact your legislators early in the game, especially if they are on committees (below) that will study the bills. (All of the names below are clickable–follow them to find phone numbers or send emails.)
The Senate bill, SB 1272, will go through the Senate Criminal Justice, Education, and Rules committees (see committee member lists below the House lists), then on to the full Senate.
Senate Education Committee
Chair: Senator Manny Diaz, Jr. (R)
Vice Chair: Senator Bill Montford (D)
Senator Dennis Baxley (R)
Senator Lori Berman (D)
Senator Janet Cruz (D)
Senator Keith Perry (R)
Senator David Simmons (R)
Senator Kelli Stargel (R)
Senate Rules Committee
Chair: Senator Lizbeth Benacquisto (R)
Vice Chair: Senator Audrey Gibson (D)
Senator Lauren Book (D)
Senator Rob Bradley (R)
Senator Jeff Brandes (R)
Senator Oscar Braynon II (D)
Senator Gary M. Farmer, Jr. (D)
Senator Anitere Flores (R)
Senator Travis Hutson (R)
Senator Tom Lee (R)
Senator Bill Montford (D)
Senator Kathleen Passidomo (R)
Senator Jose Javier Rodriguez (D)
Senator David Simmons (R)
Senator Wilton Simpson (R)
Senator Kelli Stargel (R)
Senator Perry E. Thurston, Jr. (D)
The House bill, HB 741, will make its way through the House Education and Judiciary committees (members below), then on to the full House.
House Education Committee
Chair: Sullivan, Jennifer Mae[R]
Vice Chair: Latvala, Chris[R]
Dem Ranking Member: Antone, Bruce[D]
Aloupis, Jr., Vance Arthur [R]
Bush III, Dr. James [D]
Byrd, Cord [R]
Daniels, Kimberly [D]
Donalds, Byron [R]
Fetterhoff, Elizabeth Anne [R]
Fine, Randy [R]
Hogan Johnson, Delores D. “D” [D]
Mariano, Amber [R]
Massullo, MD, Ralph E. [R]
Perez, Daniel [R]
Stone, Charlie [R]
Valdes, Susan L [D]
Williams, Patricia H. [D]
House Judiciary Committee
Chair: Renner, Paul [R]
Vice Chair: Rommel, Bob [R]
Dem Ranking Member: Diamond, Ben [D]
Alexander, Ramon [D]
Beltran, Mike [R]
Brannan III, Robert Charles “Chuck” [R]
Driskell, Fentrice [D]
Fernandez-Barquin, Juan Alfonso [R]
Fitzenhagen, Heather [R]
Geller, Joseph [D]
Gottlieb, Michael “Mike” [D]
Grant, James “J.W.” [R]
Gregory, Tommy [R]
Hill, Walter Bryan “Mike” [R]
Killebrew, Sam H. [R]
LaMarca, Chip [R]
Mercado, Amy [D]
Sirios, Tyler I. [R]
(The House version, HB 741, has already passed the Criminal Justice Subcommittee with the following voting record:)
Chair: Grant, James “J.W.” [R] – Y
Vice Chair: McClain, Stan [R] – Y
Dem Ranking Member: Grieco, Michael “Mike” [D] – Y
Bush III, Dr. James [D] – Y
Donalds, Byron [R] – Y
Eagle, Dane [R] – Y
Fernandez-Barquin, Juan Alfonso [R] – Y
Fitzenhagen, Heather [R] – Y
Gottlieb, Michael “Mike” [D] – Y
Hattersley, Adam Roger [D] – Y
Roach, Spencer [R] – Y
Robinson, Jr., William Cloud “Will” [R] – Y
Sabatini, Anthony [R] – Y
Santiago, David [R] – Y
Webb, Jennifer Necole [D] – no vote