“Just as the Third Reich lost its right to exist, so too has Israel,” Tel Hai College Dr. Ilana Hairston tells students, prompting outrage.
By Noam Dvir, Reposted from Israel Hayom, October 23, 2025
An online post by psychology professor Dr. Ilana Hairston from Tel-Hai College in northern Israel has sparked significant controversy. In content she published on October 7, two years following the Hamas atrocities, Hairston criticized the government, argued its proper place is prison, and wrote, “Just as the Third Reich forfeited its right to exist, so too has the State of Israel.” She additionally accused Israel of committing genocide, writing “genocide state.”
The post appeared after testimonies emerged from flotilla personnel arriving from Europe. Hairston wrote, “Just as murderers and rapists possess a right to exist in prison, so the Israeli leadership deserves long lives behind bars.” She continued, “The testimonies of the detainees from the flotilla are horrifying.
“The genocide state in full display – beatings, being held kneeling with hands cuffed behind the back for hours, denial of medical treatment, degrading treatment, and threats. Not to mention that abducting the people from the flotilla in international waters constitutes a violation of international maritime law.”
Tel-Hai College issued a response, “The lecturer’s serious statements were written on her personal account and do not represent the position of Tel-Hai Academic College as an academic institution. Tel-Hai Academic College stands proudly with Israeli Air Force soldiers and security forces and thanks them for their dedication and protection of the State of Israel and its citizens.
“Many of our students served in the reserves during the past two years. During this period, as we return with excitement to our northern campuses after more than two years, the opening of the academic year represents the resilience of the region and Tel-Hai’s deep commitment to the Galilee community and Israeli society.”
Professors for a Strong Israel issued a statement, “Israeli academia must not function as a sanctuary for lecturers who slander the State of Israel. Following Dr. Ilana Hairston’s statements from Tel-Hai College, comparing the State of Israel to the Third Reich, Professors for a Strong Israel warns that this represents a serious and persistent phenomenon of lecturers in higher education institutions who abuse freedom of expression to damage the State of Israel and Israeli Air Force soldiers.”
Shachar Yifrach, chairman of the Tel-Hai Student Union, stated, “Dr. Ilana Hairston’s post crosses a red line both clearly and publicly. The union vigorously condemns these statements. Comparing the State of Israel to the Third Reich is a perilous comparison that damages Holocaust memory and harms reserve soldiers, including our students who risked their lives for the state. The union adopted the IHRA definition* against antisemitism last year, and we invite the college and other institutions nationwide to adopt the definition as we have.”
*IAK NOTE: Jewish anthropologist Maura Finkelstein has this to say about the use of antisemitism accusations to distract from the reality of Israel’s violence against Palestinians: “[W]e mustn’t be distracted by antisemitism dog whistles…Resistance to the Jewish supremacist project of Zionism, which is an inherently settler colonial project of genocide, is not antisemitic. It is instead an anti-colonial form of resistance.”
Noam Dvir is a reporter for Israel Hayom.
RELATED:
- Israel uses antisemitism as cover for Gaza genocide. It’s a trap
- After crushing dissent, U.S. universities are deepening ties with Israeli academia
- Long History of Jewish Dissent Over Israel’s Treatment of Palestinians
- Nonprofits Are Taking a Stance on Gaza — and Paying the Price
- Netanyahu has a new, well-paid army to fight for Israel on social media
- Israeli Minister: Israel is investing in Diaspora Jewish education so Jews worldwide will ‘embrace Zionism’
