“I will not be bullied,” said Carrie Prejean Boller. “I have the religious freedom to refuse support for a government that is bombing civilians and starving families in Gaza, and that does not make me an antisemite.”
IAK NOTE: Pro-Israel organizations consistently work to silence Palestine advocacy on campus and elsewhere, violating the right of free speech. One strategy they use is to pressure institutions to officially adopt the IHRA “definition” of antisemitism, which defines legitimate criticism of Israel as antisemitic.
Read more about the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, which curtails legitimate criticism of Israel, here and here.
Many Israel apologists conflate all Jews with the actions of the state of Israel. They will deny that they do this, but they indisputably do. That is the message they are circulating when they accuse anyone who criticizes Israel’s actions of hating all Jews. They create antisemitism.
By Brett Wilkens, Reposted from Common Dreams, February 11, 2026
A conservative Catholic was expelled from President Donald Trump’s so-called Religious Liberty Commission this week over remarks at a hearing on antisemitism in which she pushed back against those who conflate criticism of Israel and its genocidal war on Gaza with hatred of Jewish people.
Religious Liberty Commission Chair Dan Patrick, who is also Texas’ Republican lieutenant governor, announced February 11 that Carrie Prejean Boller had been ousted from the panel, writing on X that “no member… has the right to hijack a hearing for their own personal and political agenda on any issue.”
“This is clearly, without question, what happened on February 09 in our hearing on antisemitism in America,” he claimed. “This was my decision.”
Patrick added that Trump “respects all faiths”—even though at least 13 of the commission’s remaining 15 members are Christian, only one is Jewish, and none are Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, or other religions to which millions of Americans adhere. A coalition of faith groups this week filed a federal lawsuit over what one critic described as the commission’s rejection of “our nation’s religious diversity and prioritizing one narrow set of conservative ‘Judeo-Christian’ beliefs.”
Noting that Israeli forces have killed “tens of thousands of civilians in Gaza,” Prejean Boller asked panel participant and University of California Los Angeles law student Yitzchok Frankel, who is Jewish, “In a country built on religious liberty and the First Amendment, do you believe someone can stand firmly against antisemitism… and at the same time, condemn the mass killing of Palestinians in Gaza, or reject political Zionism, or not support the political state of Israel?”
“Or do you believe that speaking out about what many Americans view as genocide in Gaza should be treated as antisemitic?” added Prejean Boller, who also took aim at the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) Working Definition of Antisemitism, which has been widely condemned for conflating criticism of Israel with anti-Jewish bigotry.
Frankel replied “yes” to the assertion that anti-Zionism is antisemitic.
Prejean Boller also came under fire for wearing pins of the US and Palestinian flags during Monday’s hearing.
“I wore an American flag pin next to a Palestinian flag as a moral statement of solidarity with civilians who are being bombed, displaced, and deliberately starved in Gaza,” Prejean Boller said on February 10 on X in response to calls for her resignation from the commission.
“I did this after watching many participants ignore, minimize, or outright deny what is plainly visible: a campaign of mass killing and starvation of a trapped population,” she continued. “Silence in the face of that is not religious liberty, it is moral complicity. My Christian faith calls on me to stand for those who are suffering and in need.”
“Forcing people to affirm Zionism as a condition of participation is not only wrong, it is directly contrary to religious freedom, especially on a body created to protect conscience,” Prejean Boller stressed. “As a Catholic, I have both a constitutional right and a God-given freedom of religion and conscience not to endorse a political ideology or a government that is carrying out mass civilian killing and starvation.”
Forcing people to affirm Zionism on a “Religious Liberty” Commission is the opposite of religious freedom.
I will not resign, and I will not be bullied for following my Catholic conscience. My response to @ShabbosK pic.twitter.com/ecrKvZJVK2
— Carrie Prejean Boller (@CarriePrejean1) February 10, 2026
Zionism is the movement for a homeland for the Jewish people in Palestine—their ancestral birthplace—under the belief that God gave them the land. It has also been criticized as a settler-colonial and racist ideology, as in order to secure a Jewish homeland, Zionists have engaged in ethnic cleansing, occupation, invasions, and genocide against Palestinian Arabs.
Prejean Boller was Miss California in 2009 and Miss USA runner-up that same year. She launched her career as a Christian activist during the latter pageant after she answered a question about same-sex marriage by saying she opposed it. Then-businessman Trump owned most of Miss USA at the time and publicly supported Prejean Boller, saying, “It wasn’t a bad answer.”
Since then, Prejean Boller has been known for her anti-LGBTQ+ statements and for paying parents and children for going without masks during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) commended Prejean Boller on February 11 “for using her position to oppose conflating criticism of Israel with antisemitism and encourage solidarity between Muslims, Christians, and Jews,” calling her “one of a growing number of Americans, including political conservatives, who recognize that corrupted politicians have been trying to silence and smear Americans critical of the Israeli government under the guise of countering antisemitism.”
“We also condemn Texas Lt. Gov. Patrick’s baseless and predictable decision to remove her from the commission for refusing to conflate antisemitism with criticism of the Israeli apartheid government,” CAIR added.
In her statement Tuesday, Prejean Boller said, “I will not be bullied.”
“I have the religious freedom to refuse support for a government that is bombing civilians and starving families in Gaza, and that does not make me an antisemite,” she insisted. “It makes me a pro-life Catholic and a free American who will not surrender religious liberty to political pressure.”
“Zionist supremacy has no place on an American religious liberty commission,” Prejean Boller added.
Brett Wilkens is a staff writer for Common Dreams.
RELATED:
- Trump Admin Enacts Vast Censorship of American Scientists Over Israel
- U.S. Envoys Refused to Report “Apocalyptic” Conditions in Gaza. Exclusive Photos Show the Reality They Suppressed
- Across the West, speaking for Palestine is now a crime
- Oppose Israel’s Abuses While You Still Can
- Genocide isn’t a mistake. Which is why the media can’t tell you the truth about Gaza
